What are 412(i) Plans and what are the problems with these plans

412(i) is a provision of the tax code. A 412(i) plan is a defined pension plan. A 412(i) plan differs from other defined benefit pension plans in that it must be funded exclusively by the purchase of individual life insurance products (insurance and annuities). It provides specific retirement benefits to participants once they reach retirement and must contain assets sufficient to pay those benefits. To create a 412(i) plan, there must be a plan to hold the assets. The employer funds the plan by making cash contributions to the plan, and the Code allows the employer to take a tax deduction in the amount of the contributions, i.e. the entire amount.

The plan uses the contributed funds to purchase some combination of life insurance products (insurance or annuities) for the plan. As the plan participants retire, the plan will usually sell the policies for their present cash value and purchase annuities with the proceeds. The revenue stream from the annuities pays the specified retirement benefit to plan participants.

Where did the problems start?

In the late 1990's brokers and promoters such as Kenneth Hartstein, Dennis Cunning, and others began selling 412(i) plans designed with policies created and sold through agents of Pacific Life, Hartford, Indianapolis life, and American General. These plans were sold or administered through companies such as Economic Concepts, Inc., Pension Professionals of America, Pension Strategies, L.L.C. and others.

These plans were very lucrative for the brokers, promoters, agents, and insurance companies. In addition to the costs associated with administering the plans, the policies of insurance had high commissions and high surrender charges.

These plans were often described as Pendulum Plans, or other similar names. In theory, the plans would work as follows. After the defined pension plan was set up, the plan would purchase a life insurance policy insuring the life of an individual. The plan would have no cash value (and high surrender charges) for 5 or more years. The Corporation would pay the premium on the policy and take a deduction for the entire amount. In year 5, when the policy had little or no cash value, the plan would transfer the policy to the individual, who would take it at a greatly reduced basis. Subsequently, the policy would bloom like a rose, and the individual would have a policy with significant cash value which he or she could withdraw tax free.

Who signed off on the plan?

Attorney Richard Smith at the law firm of Bryan Cave issued tax opinion letters opinion which stated that many of the plans complied with the tax code.

So what is the problem?

In the early 2000s, IRS officials began questioning Richard Smith and others and giving speeches at benefits conferences wherein they took the position that these plans were in violation of both the letter and spirit of the Internal Revenue Code.

In February 2004, the IRS issued guidance on 412(i) and began the process of making plans "listed transactions." Taxpayers involved in listed transaction are required to report them to the IRS. These transactions are to be reported using a form 8886. The failure to file a form 8886 subjects individual to penalties of $100,000 per year, and corporations $200,000 per year. These penalties are often referred to as section 6707 penalties. Advisors of these plans are required to maintain records regarding these plans and turn them over to the IRS, upon demand.

In October of 2005, the IRS invited those who sponsored 412(i) plans that were treated as listed transactions to enter a settlement program in which the taxpayer would recind the plan and pay the income taxes it would have paid had it not engaged in the plan, plus interest and reduced penalties.In late 2005, the IRS began obtaining information from advisors and actively auditing plans and more recently, levying section 6707 penalties.

You may contact Chris Hellums at Chrish@pdkhlaw.com

For more information on 412(i) litigation, see http://412ilitigation.blogspot.com/